Facebook fined $887 million for accessing users' private photos without proper consent

Filip TRUȚĂ

November 17, 2026

Facebook fined $887 million for accessing users' private photos without proper consent

Italy's privacy watchdog has imposed a massive fine on Meta after finding that Facebook accessed Android users' photos, videos and metadata through a feature enabled by default, without obtaining specific consent.

Facebook parent company Meta has been fined €805 million ($887 million) by Italy's data protection authority for accessing photos and videos stored on Android smartphones without properly informing users or obtaining their specific consent.

The penalty, announced Nov. 14, follows an investigation into a Facebook feature that suggests photos and videos from a user's personal gallery while they browse the social network.

According to Italy's Data Protection Authority, known as the Garante, the practice potentially affected 20 million Android users in Italy.

The regulator found that Facebook's permission system allowed access to users' photo libraries for purposes they may not have understood or explicitly agreed to.

Key points

  • Italy has fined Meta €805 million ($887 million) over Facebook's access to Android users' photos and videos
  • The feature was enabled by default and relied on a broad permission covering multiple Facebook functions
  • Approximately 20 million Android users in Italy were affected, according to the regulator
  • Meta must disable the feature by default and obtain separate, informed consent within 60 days
  • Meta disputes the decision and plans to appeal

How Facebook accessed users' photo galleries

The investigation centers on a feature called "Get camera roll suggestions when you're browsing Facebook," introduced in 2023.

The feature is designed to make posting easier by suggesting photos and videos stored on a user's phone while they browse Facebook.

However, investigators found that the app requested access to the phone's photo gallery through a single permission covering several functions, rather than seeking authorization specifically for the suggestions feature.

The notice preceding the permission request refered to enabling additional features but didn’t clearly explain that users were allowing Facebook to access their personal photo libraries for content suggestions.

Worse, the feature was enabled by default.

The Garante warned that granting full photo access could allow Facebook to read an Android device's entire photo library, potentially on a permanent basis, and users couldn’t verify exactly which information was being used.

That access could include photographs, videos and associated metadata stored on the device.

This doesn’t mean Facebook automatically uploaded every photo or video to its servers. The regulator's findings concern the scope of access and the absence of valid, specific consent, not proof that every image was transferred.

Why Italy says Meta violated privacy law

The investigation began in July 2025 following a complaint from a consumer protection organization in Bolzano, Italy.

The Garante concluded that Meta violated Article 122 of Italy's Data Protection Code, which implements the European Union's ePrivacy Directive.

The provision protects information stored on personal devices and requires users to provide free and informed consent before an application accesses that information.

The regulator said the requirement applies regardless of whether the information is transmitted elsewhere or whether users suffer demonstrable harm.

In determining the penalty, the authority considered the approximately 20 million people affected, the duration of the violation, a previous regulatory decision against Meta in 2019, and what it described as the company's poor cooperation during the investigation.

The €805 million fine represents approximately 0.47% of Meta's global annual revenue.

The regulator acknowledged that Meta had introduced changes following the complaint, but considered them insufficient because they came late and applied only to users who updated the app.

Meta disputes the fine and plans to appeal

Meta said it intends to appeal the decision.

In a statement, the company described the penalty as disproportionate and argued that Facebook users must first grant Android photo permissions before the feature can operate.

Meta also maintained that users can revoke those permissions through their device settings.

Italy's regulator argues that a general Android permission does not automatically constitute valid consent for every Facebook feature that might use it.

Meta also challenged the Italian authority's jurisdiction, arguing that the matter should fall under Ireland's privacy regulator. The Garante rejected that argument, saying the ePrivacy rules involved do not follow the GDPR's one-stop-shop enforcement mechanism.

What about Meta's AI training?

The case also raises questions about how personal photographs might be used beyond Facebook's content suggestions.

However, the Garante explicitly stated that its investigation did not examine whether Meta used photos or videos from Android users' galleries to train artificial intelligence models.

Meta denies using the content for AI training.

The regulator said it may separately investigate another feature introduced in 2026 that allows photo gallery content to be processed in the cloud.

The €805 million fine concerns unauthorized access and inadequate consent, not a finding that Meta used private photos to train AI.

Meta ordered to change Facebook's photo access

The Garante gave Meta 60 days to bring the feature into compliance.

Meta must obtain separate, specific consent for camera roll suggestions and clearly explain what the feature does, how it accesses personal photos, and how users can disable it.

The feature must also remain disabled by default, including for people who previously granted Facebook access to their photo libraries.

Meta must report the steps it has taken toward compliance within 30 days and the measures it has adopted within 90 days.

If the company fails to comply within the 60-day deadline, it will be prohibited from enabling the feature for Italian Android users who have not provided valid consent.

How to stop Facebook from accessing your photos on Android

Regardless of where they live, Android users can review Facebook's access to their personal photo libraries and restrict permissions they no longer want to grant.

1.     Open your Android phone's Settings

2.     Go to Apps and select Facebook

3.     Tap Permissions, then Photos and videos

4.     Select Don't allow if you want to block Facebook from accessing your photo library, or Select photos and videos if your device offers limited access

5.     Open Facebook and review any camera roll suggestions or photo-sharing settings, disabling features you don't use

Note: The exact menu names and available permission options depend on your Android version and phone manufacturer. Restricting access may affect Facebook features that rely on photos and videos.

Users should also review permissions granted to other social media apps, particularly the apps with access to their camera, microphone, contacts and location.

Granting an app access to personal files can expose more information than users intended to share.

A permission granted to upload a single photo should not be mistaken for informed consent to let an app use an entire photo library for unrelated features.

On topic:

Google hit with €403 million fine over location tracking

TikTok pays $400 million to settle children’s privacy case

Britain’s big push to make the internet safer

tags


Author


Filip TRUȚĂ

Filip has 17 years of experience in technology journalism. In recent years, he has focused on cybersecurity in his role as a Security Analyst at Bitdefender.

View all posts

You might also like

Bookmarks


loader