Rental scams: How to spot and avoid fake rental listings

Scammers create fake rental listings for attractive properties, copy legitimate ads, impersonate landlords, and pressure people into paying deposits or sharing personal information.

Some rental scams can be surprisingly hard to spot, even when you visit the apartment in person. In one recent story shared on Reddit, the victim visited the real apartment, attended a legitimate open house, and met the actual owner, and still lost $18,600 to a scammer.

Here's how rental scams work, what to check before you pay, and what to do if you've already sent money or personal information to a fake landlord.

Key takeaways:

Rental scammers may copy legitimate property listings or advertise homes that aren't actually available.
Seeing a property in person doesn't guarantee that the person you're communicating with online is the real landlord or agent.
Search the property address and verify the landlord or rental company independently before paying.
Be especially careful when you're asked to wire money, pay in cryptocurrency, or use gift cards.
Rental scams can lead to identity theft as well as financial loss because fake applications may collect sensitive personal information.
If you've sent money to a scammer, contact your bank or payment provider immediately.

How do rental scams work?

Rental scams can take several forms, but they all try to convince you that a property is legitimately available long enough to steal your money or personal information.

1. Scammers copy real rental listings

Scammers copy the photos, description, address, virtual tour, and other details from a legitimate listing. They then repost it on another website or marketplace, replacing the landlord's or agent's contact information with their own.

When you contact the person in the fake ad, you're talking to the scammer.

They may ask you to pay an application fee, security deposit, first month's rent, or other upfront costs. Or they may send you a rental application asking for sensitive information that can later be used for identity theft.

2. Scammers advertise properties that aren't actually for rent

The property may already be occupied, listed for sale rather than rent, or belong to somebody who has no idea their home is being advertised.

When you ask for a viewing, the supposed landlord may claim they're traveling, living abroad, dealing with a family emergency, or otherwise unable to meet you.

Then comes the pressure: other people are interested, the apartment will go quickly, and you need to send a deposit now if you want to secure it.

3. Scammers impersonate real landlords or property managers

Scammers can find the real owner's name, property information, company details, and other information online and use it to make their story more convincing.

This is important because simply searching the landlord's name and confirming that the person exists isn't enough. You also need to make sure the email address, phone number, application process, and payment instructions actually belong to them.

And sometimes even seeing the property isn't enough.

A rental scam where the apartment and the open house were real

A Reddit user shared how they lost $18,600 to a particularly convincing rental scam involving a two-bedroom apartment in San Francisco.

They found the property listed on both Zillow and Craigslist and responded to the Craigslist ad. They attended an open house where everything checked out: the apartment was real and vacant, and the person showing it was the actual owner.

The scam happened afterward. They continued communicating through the Craigslist email thread, submitted an application, signed a lease, and wired $18,600 for rent and the security deposit. They even discussed utilities and arranged a time to collect the keys.

But nobody showed up for the key handoff. When they contacted the Zillow listing, they discovered that the real owner had hosted the open house but had never posted on Craigslist, communicated with them afterward, signed the lease, or received the money.

The victim immediately contacted the banks and reported the fraud to law enforcement, the FBI's IC3, the FTC, and local authorities. Unfortunately, the bank was unable to recover the money.

How to tell if a rental listing is legitimate

Before you pay or share personal information, check the property, the person you're dealing with, and the payment instructions.

Search the property address. Look for other listings for the same property. Different landlords, contact details, prices, or a home listed for sale rather than rent can be red flags.
Compare the price. Rent that's significantly below similar properties in the area deserves extra scrutiny, especially if you're pressured to act quickly.
Verify the landlord independently. If it's a rental company, find its official website and contact it directly. For private landlords, check property ownership records where available. Don't just verify that the landlord's name is real, make sure the person you're communicating with is actually that landlord.
Confirm what happens after a viewing. Ask the landlord or agent directly where to apply, how they'll contact you, and how payments are handled. Get their contact details while you're there rather than relying on the person who originally contacted you online.
Verify before you pay. Confirm the recipient and payment details using contact information you've independently verified. Be particularly cautious if the payment details suddenly change.
Watch for pressure and unusual payment methods. Don't let claims that other renters are waiting rush you into paying. Requests for gift cards, cryptocurrency, wire transfers, or other difficult-to-reverse payments are major warning signs.

Use Bitdefender free tools to investigate rental listings

When you're researching a rental listing or the person behind it, a few online tools can help you dig deeper:

·Scamio can analyze suspicious rental messages, emails, links, or screenshots and flag signs of a scam.

·Link Checker can help you check whether a link from a rental ad, application, or message is safe before you open it.

·Reverse Phone Lookup can give you more information about the phone number a supposed landlord or agent is using and help you check whether the number has been associated with suspicious activity.

These tools can give you more information, but they can't make the final decision for you. Trust your instincts and stay cautious. If something doesn't add up, you're being rushed to pay, or the person avoids reasonable verification, don't let the fear of losing a great apartment push you into taking a risk.

What to do if you've been scammed by a fake rental listing

Contact your bank, card issuer, money-transfer company, or other payment provider immediately. Explain that the transaction was fraudulent and ask whether it can be stopped, recalled, or investigated. The sooner you report it, the better.

Also, save as much evidence as possible before the scammer disappears or the listing is removed and report the fake listing to the website or platform where you found it.

In the US, rental fraud can also be reported to the Federal Trade Commission at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and, for internet-enabled fraud, to the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3). You can also contact local law enforcement and your state attorney general.

If you shared sensitive personal information, take steps to protect your identity as well: change compromised or reused passwords, monitor your financial accounts, and consider placing a fraud alert or credit freeze if information such as your Social Security number was exposed.

You may also want to read:

FAQs

How can I tell if a rental listing is fake?

Search the property address online, compare the rent with similar properties, check for duplicate listings, and independently verify the landlord or property manager. Be cautious if you're pressured to pay quickly, can't verify who you're dealing with, or are asked to use a difficult-to-reverse payment method.

Can you get scammed even if you see the apartment in person?

Yes. Seeing the property proves that the property exists, but it doesn't necessarily prove that the person you've been communicating with is authorized to rent it. Scammers may copy legitimate listings, take advantage of real open houses, or use self-guided tours to make fake rental offers appear legitimate.

How do I verify a landlord before paying a deposit?

Find the landlord or property manager's contact information independently and confirm the rental and payment instructions directly with them. If you attended a viewing, ask the person showing the property exactly how applications and payments are handled and get their contact information directly.

What information should I not give a potential landlord?

Avoid sharing highly sensitive information until you've verified that the landlord, agent, and property are legitimate. Be especially careful with Social Security numbers, copies of identification documents, bank information, pay stubs, and other information that could be used for identity theft.

What should I do if I paid a rental scammer?

Contact your bank or payment provider immediately and report the transaction as fraud. Ask whether the payment can be stopped or recalled. Save all evidence, report the fake listing to the platform, and report the fraud to the relevant authorities. If you also shared personal information, take steps to protect yourself against identity theft.

Can I get my money back after a rental scam?

It may be possible in some cases, particularly if you report the fraud quickly enough for the payment to be stopped or recalled, but recovery isn't guaranteed. Some payment methods are particularly difficult to reverse once the scammer has received the funds.