1 min read

Authorities Can"t Force Suspects to Unlock Phones with Biometrics, Rules California Court

Luana PASCU

January 15, 2019

Ad One product to protect all your devices, without slowing them down.
Free 90-day trial
Authorities Can"t Force Suspects to Unlock Phones with Biometrics, Rules California Court

A California court has ruled that government agencies can”t compel suspects to unlock their smart devices with biometric authentication because it violates the self-incrimination clause in the Fifth Amendment, writes Forbes. This applies even if a warrant has been granted to search the person”s residence.

The decision was made after law enforcement filed for a search warrant while investigating two suspects in Oakland, California, allegedly involved in a Facebook extortion case. The men were accused of using Facebook Messenger to harass and threaten another man with publishing a humiliating video online.

While searching the suspects” house, federal authorities wanted to also investigate the contents of all mobile devices on premises but, to be unlocked, the individuals would have to use biometric features such as fingerprint of facial recognition to unlock them. Their warrant request was denied.

“The Government cannot be permitted to search and seize a mobile phone or other device that is on a non-suspect”s person simply because they are present during an otherwise lawful search,” reads the ruling.

Courts in the US earlier ruled that “a passcode cannot be compelled under the Fifth Amendment, because the act of communicating the passcode is testimonial,” but didn”t include biometrics. Judge Kandis Westmore now ruled that biometric features are innovative passcodes and should benefit from the same protection, so police can no longer force suspects to unlock their devices.

“While the judge agreed that investigators had shown probable cause to search the property, they didn”t have the right to open all devices inside by forcing unlocks with biometric features,” says Forbes.

“If a person cannot be compelled to provide a passcode because it is a testimonial communication, a person cannot be compelled to provide one”s finger, thumb, iris, face, or other biometric feature to unlock that same device,” the judge wrote.

“The undersigned finds that a biometric feature is analogous to the 20 nonverbal, physiological responses elicited during a polygraph test, which are used to determine guilt or innocence, and are considered testimonial.”

tags


Author



Right now

Top posts

Abode IoT Security Camera Vulnerabilities Would Let Attackers Insert Images, Bitdefender Finds

Abode IoT Security Camera Vulnerabilities Would Let Attackers Insert Images, Bitdefender Finds

December 21, 2021

2 min read
Online Shoppers Beware, Mobile Scams Are on the Rise

Online Shoppers Beware, Mobile Scams Are on the Rise

December 17, 2021

2 min read
The Holiday Guide to Tech Support: Fixing the Family Computer

The Holiday Guide to Tech Support: Fixing the Family Computer

November 24, 2021

2 min read
Bitdefender Celebrates 20 Years of Cybersecurity Leadership

Bitdefender Celebrates 20 Years of Cybersecurity Leadership

November 04, 2021

3 min read
Bitdefender Study Reveals How Consumers Like (and Dislike) Managing Passwords

Bitdefender Study Reveals How Consumers Like (and Dislike) Managing Passwords

October 26, 2021

3 min read
What are drive-by download attacks and how do you prevent them?

What are drive-by download attacks and how do you prevent them?

October 25, 2021

2 min read

FOLLOW US ON

SOCIAL MEDIA


You might also like

Malware Posing as Ransomware Responsible for Ukraine Cyberattack Malware Posing as Ransomware Responsible for Ukraine Cyberattack
Silviu STAHIE

January 17, 2022

2 min read
Russian Authorities Cuff Last Remaining REvil Suspects Russian Authorities Cuff Last Remaining REvil Suspects
Filip TRUȚĂ

January 17, 2022

2 min read
Android 12 protects phones from Stingray attacks, lets users disable 2G Android 12 protects phones from Stingray attacks, lets users disable 2G
Radu CRAHMALIUC

January 14, 2022

1 min read